The Your Sinclair Rock'n'Roll Years
Front PageSearch SiteE-Mail MeArticle IndexJoystick Jugglers
Screenshot
Loader
YS Scan
Click images to enlarge
2D Game Maker
CRL £8.95 Nov 1988 YS35
Graphics: 4/10
Playability: 3/10
VFM: 3/10
Addictiveness: 2/10
3/10 Overall
 
Search WOS
Get tips for this game
Designer boredom. A utility involving 3D effort to create 2D games of 1D possiblities. Perfect for masochists.
David McCandless
Let's face it, I went wild when this package hit my doorstep, but so would anyone who's ever tried to get to grips with Melboume House's 'cos anything's gotta be better than that for DIY game-making. Hasn't it? Well hasn't it??
    Well, no! 2D Game Maker is definitely worse. It starts with a demo game with a fair number of screens being loaded along with the designer into the Spectrum. The graphics are of a reasonably high standard and the animation is very smooth. Unfortunately, it's all bad news from then on. The only thing that moves is your character, so the quality of animation isn't surprising and the scrolling messages are trite - even if they are a nice touch. Objects picked up once reappear next time you reach the screen, so at least you can build up reasonable scores.
    The demo is the graphic adventure type where you have to pick up objects and use them in other rooms. You plck up the objects by accessing a menu using the 'Function' key. But the function appears to be 'Zap' 'cos all I ever managed to achieve was a complete crash. Also beware entering names for saving/loading your game designs (another bug in my book) since too long a name causes the program to crash back to Basic.
    The default cursor keys are the familiar Q, A, O, P and M for 'fire'. Keys 1-5 are used in the object design screens, and allow some of the functions to work with a joystick.
    But to add to the user-unfriendliness of the thing, the QUIT option of some menus is absent in others, so to get back to a previous level, you have to start from the beginning and work down again. In the screen design function, each time you want to place an object the menu comes up again - which makes for really slow screen design. All in all, there's a noticeable lack of continuity between the menus, how you get to them and what to do once you get there. At least the icons on the main menu bar are somewhat recognisable.
    After a short while, it is soon apparent that the only games that can be created are ones very much like the demo - platforms or flat graphic adventures - so the possibilities are absolutely endless if repetition tums you on. The 'fire' key is entirely pointless as the only moving sprite is the controlled character, - so no shoot 'em ups.
    And there you have it. A cumbersome, highly complicated utility for creating pretty but boring games. Avoid, avoid, a thousand times avoid.

Ratings given by other magazines
   CRASH  5/10   
Info supplied by the SPOT*ON database

David McCandless has kindly authorised this site
Visit (David's website) and see what he's up to nowadays!
Reviews in other magazines:
   
 
Crash
 
Click pages to enlarge
LOOKING FOR EX-YS WRITERS! Do you know where any are?
READERS NOTE: The original YS articles on this site were written many many years ago, and should provide no indication WHATSOEVER of the author's present writing style. Judge these people on their current work, not articles they wrote decades ago.
All original YS text is still copyright to their original owners, including BOTH publishers and authors. Permission has been granted to reproduce these articles by a few of these owners - if you see your work on here and would like it to be taken down, e-mail me and I'll do it straightaway. All other pages have similar restrictions - email me for more details.
    None of the pages on this website may be reproduced in any way, nor sold to the general public (i.e. put onto a CD-ROM) without the consent of Nick Humphries and the author of each article. If you want to include any of these articles on a site or a CD, contact me for more instructions.
Date Time